Bsfl
BSFL vs Dubia Roaches: Complete Comparison
BSFL vs Dubia Roaches: Different Feeders, Different Strengths
BSFL and dubia roaches (or their legal equivalent, discoid roaches) are both premium feeder insects — but they specialize in completely different nutritional areas. BSFL are the calcium specialist; roaches are the protein specialist. Understanding this makes them complementary, not competitive.
| Nutrient | BSFL | Discoid/Dubia Roaches |
|---|---|---|
| Protein | ~17% | ~20-23% |
| Fat | ~14% | ~7% |
| Calcium | 9,340 mg/kg | 200 mg/kg |
| Ca:P Ratio | 6.92:1 | 0.77:1 |
| Moisture | ~61% | ~65% |
| Dusting needed? | No | Yes |
| Gut-loadable? | No | Yes — excellent |
| Storage | Fridge, 2-3 weeks | Room temp, weeks-months |
| Legality | Legal everywhere | Discoids legal everywhere; dubias banned in FL |
The Key Difference: Protein vs Calcium
Roaches win on protein (20-23% vs 17%) and fat efficiency (7% vs 14%). BSFL win on calcium by a factor of 47x (9,340 vs 200 mg/kg). Roaches are the daily protein staple; BSFL are the calcium supplement you add 1-3 times per week.
They Work Best Together
This is not an either/or choice — it is a both/and. The ideal feeding rotation uses both:
- Daily: Discoid roaches — dust with calcium + D3
- 1-3x/week: BSFL — no dusting needed
- 2-3x/week: Silkworms — ultra-low fat supplement
- 1-2x/week: Hornworms — hydration
Roaches provide the protein foundation. BSFL provide the calcium safety net. Together they address the two most important nutritional needs of captive reptiles.
Legality Note
Dubia roaches are banned in Florida. Discoid roaches are the legal equivalent — same nutrition, legal in all 50 states. BSFL are legal everywhere with no restrictions.
At All Angles Creatures, we carry both discoid roaches and BSFL — the complete protein + calcium combination your reptile needs.
— Matt, Founder, All Angles Creatures
Last updated